We're sorry to hear that these cookies weren't quite what you were expecting, Dennis! We're not familiar with the Cool-Whip cookies you're referring to so it's tricky to suggest a recipe that might be closer to what you were hoping for, maybe our Fudge Drops or Chocolate Meringue Kisses are closer to what you were hoping for? We're happy to share your feedback about the yeild of this recipe with our Test Kitchen team for their consideration and we thank you for taking the time to share all these details! 

• Reply