I have been on the hunt for Rooster Brother's molasses cookie recipe for years. Rooster Brothers is similar to your Cape pie shop. They reside in Ellsworth,Maine , and have a cookie in their coffee shop to die for. Anytime I hear the recipe is a secret, I am hopelessly hooked . I've corresponded with Susan Reid over the years to see if she can rekindle her Maine contacts to get the cookie recipe or their sandwich roll secrets for the Baking Sheet . Please don't give up until you have tasted the Maine real thing !!
I haven't given up at all - these cookies are wonderful. And I'm guessing I must have sampled Rooster Bros. at one time, as I used to live in Camden and we visited Ellsworth quite a bit for various high school sports trips... Wish I had one right now, for comparison! PJH
January 11, 2012 at 8:12am