The bakers of King Arthur are here to solve the kitchen conundrums you share with us, whether on the phone, computer, or by the good old postal service. In Ask the Baker’s Hotline, Annabelle picks the brains of the talented King Arthur Baker’s Hotline to tackle your most-asked questions. Today’s query: Why are my cookies flat?
* * *
If you’re trying to bake a batch of thick, chewy cookies, the last thing you want is to pull out a tray of thin, crispy ones. Xander over on our Baker’s Hotline is here to explain why cookies sometimes come out flat, how to ensure it doesn't happen to your next batch, and how to use flat cookies if you end up with a less-than-ideal batch.
Why did my cookies come out flat?
Flat cookies can happen for various reasons, but the good news is that most of these issues can be fixed with a few easy adjustments.
Over-creaming butter and sugar
“The number one reason cookies turn out flat is over-creaming the butter and sugar,” Xander says. The creaming process is a key step in many cookie recipes to incorporate air, which is crucial for the cookie’s structure. “If over-creamed, the butter can come out of emulsion (the fat and water in the butter separate), and the fat leaks out while baking, leading to flat, greasy cookies.” To avoid this, cream the butter and sugar just until they are light and fluffy, about 2 to 3 minutes. See this blog for step-by-step visuals.
Too little flour, too much sugar
Because flour provides integral structure to the dough, “not using enough flour causes cookies to spread too much,” explains Xander. Measure your flour with a scale for consistent accuracy, as seen here. In the same vein, too much sugar leads to the same flat results. “Sugar melts while baking, becoming a liquid ingredient and causing the dough to spread,” Xander shares. If your cookies are consistently coming out flat, weigh your sugar to ensure you're using the right amount. And if your cookies are still flat, try reducing the sugar in your recipe by a tablespoon or two.
You didn’t chill the dough
Chilling the dough before baking is crucial for preventing flat cookies. “When the dough is chilled, the butter takes longer to melt, allowing the cookie to set properly,” Xander says. For best results, chill the dough for at least 30 minutes to an hour, or overnight if possible — don’t skip this step if your recipe calls for it! Our Recipe of the Year, Supersized, Super-Soft Chocolate Chip Cookies, uses an overnight rest to prevent flat cookies (and, as a bonus, ensure deeper flavor too).
Baking on the wrong surface
We tested cookies on a variety of baking surfaces to determine which method resulted in the best cookies and found that a foil-lined baking sheet led to thin, flat cookies. Instead, use a baking sheet lined with (un-greased) parchment paper or a silicone cookie mat for thick, chewy cookies.
Your oven is too cold
If your oven is too cool while baking, the cookies can spread too much before they’ve set and wind up flat. Always use an oven thermometer to make sure you’re baking at the correct temperature.
A secret ingredient to prevent flat cookies: Instant ClearJel
If your cookies still turn out flat despite your best efforts, try adding 1/2 tablespoon of Instant ClearJel to the dough. Instant ClearJel is a thickening agent that absorbs excess moisture, giving the dough a stable structure and helping cookies bake up thicker. For this and many other reasons, it’s a must-have pantry staple.
What can I do with flat cookies?
“Even if your cookies turn out flatter than you'd like, there are plenty of ways to repurpose them,” Xander shares.
- Use them in ice cream: Turn any ice cream flavor into cookies and cream by adding the flat (and chopped) cookies into homemade ice cream near the end of churning.
- Turn them into cookie butter: Make your own cookie butter by combining 4 parts room-temperature cookies to 1 part butter, 1 part vegetable oil, and 1 to 2 parts brown sugar in a food processor. Add a pinch of salt and dash of vanilla for extra flavor. If it’s too thick, drizzle in about a tablespoon of boiling water. (This isn't suggested for filled cookies, like jam-filled Linzer cookies or ganache-filled sandwich cookies.)
If this post made you especially hungry for cookies, start with Supersized, Super-Soft Chocolate Chip Cookies. It took 1,200 cookies to perfect the recipe — you won’t regret it!
Cover photo (Cowboy Cookies) and food styling by Liz Neily.
Tagged:
Filed Under:
Tips and Techniques
