Carol, pastry cream can be tricky. Yes, you probably should have cooked it longer; try that next time you make it. Or do as I do — use instant pudding mix made with heavy cream and spiked with extra vanilla. Incredibly tasty, and you never have to worry about whether it'll be thick enough. Good luck — PJH
May 28, 2017 at 9:49pm
In reply to I made this for our annual trek to OBX with friends and it was … by Carol H REIGHTER (not verified)