What did I do wrong? They were more like little muffins than cookies? Mine were very soft and puffy. Hello Mary Ann - Did you use a mixer or did you do these by hand? Is it possible you over creamed the butter with the sugar? And/or over mixed while adding your eggs? If so, you may have developed too much air in your batter. Mixers can overdue it if you are not careful. Puffy pumpkins are not a bad thing, or? More room for decorations! Elisabeth @ King Arthur Flour

• Reply